SodaStream vs Drinkmate vs Aarke: which soda maker is best for zero-proof home carbonation?

The difference between carbonating water and carbonating a finished mocktail blend is bigger than it seems. Most soda makers — including all SodaStream models — are explicitly designed and warrantied only for plain water. Carbonating sugary, acidic, or protein-rich liquids in these machines creates pressure irregularities and can void the warranty. Drinkmate's OmniFizz uses a patented fizz infuser that allows safe carbonation of almost any beverage.

Aarke Carbonator Pro: Swedish design, all-metal construction, compatible with standard CO2 cylinders (SodaStream, MyDrink). Produces some of the finest, most consistent bubbles on the consumer market. A 60g CO2 cylinder carbonates about 60 liters of water. Beautiful on a countertop. Limitation: water only, officially. Some users carbonate cold brew with it successfully, but it's not intended for this use case.

Drinkmate OmniFizz: Plastic build, slightly bulkier, but the integrated fizz infuser prevents spills and over-pressurization when carbonating liquids with sugar or acid. Compatible with standard 60g cylinders. For zero-proof cocktail making at home, this is the workhorse: you can carbonate a finished shrub-citrus base, a cold brew mix or a kombucha blend directly. About 25-30% less carbonation efficiency per cylinder compared to Aarke.

SodaStream Duo / Terra: Excellent value, wide cylinder availability at supermarkets, easy cylinder exchange program. Best for households that primarily drink sparkling water and then build zero-proof cocktails by adding sparkling water to pre-made bases — the indirect method. Not for direct drink carbonation.

For the Belgian market, all three brands are available online, and SodaStream cylinders can be exchanged at major supermarkets (Delhaize, Carrefour). Zeroproof.one maintains an updated comparison of carbonation equipment available in Belgium with reader reviews from zero-proof enthusiasts.

Related questions